Listen to the Father of Fracking - Shale Reporter : Suzie Gilbert

News, information and opinion about fracking, drilling and politics in the Marcellus Shale region

Listen to the Father of Fracking

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Thursday, February 7, 2013 10:37 am

Here’s an idea: let’s take the sulfuric acid-filled, day-glo orange creek and river water streaming out of mines, truck it away, and use it for fracking.

Pennsylvania’s Department of Environmental Protection has finalized its white paper outlining the possible procedures required if mine influenced water (MIW) were allowed to be used as frackwater. Frackers in the U.S. are using about 40 billion gallons of fresh and treated water per year, the supply is dwindling, and people are looking for alternatives.

Citing how many gallons of polluted water flows from mines into Pennsylvania’s waterways each day (300 million), how many miles of rivers and streams have already been polluted (5,500), how much the state spends annually on abandoned mine reclamation ($19 million), and how much it would take to actually fix the problem ($50 billion), DEP says it’s a win-win proposition.

Mine influenced water (MIW) occurs when iron sulfide-containing rocks such as pyrite (fool’s gold) are crushed and exposed to either oxygen or the dissolved oxygen in water, first creating sulfate, then sulfuric acid. This corrosive chemical is not only highly toxic and capable of poisoning rivers and streams itself, but it will leach heavy metals such as arsenic, copper and lead from underwater rocks, poisoning the waterway still further.

Normally, nothing can survive in this type of water but certain very hardy microbes which, in turn, stimulate the production of more sulfuric acid. This creates a hazardous environment that can persist for not hundreds but thousands of years. Many closed or abandoned mines have been declared Superfund sites, which need constant monitoring so they don’t contaminate nearby aquifers.

The state has already encouraged gas companies to use this kind of water, but no one wants to hear about it because of liability issues. If you move contaminated water, you own it, and you are responsible should any problems arise. So the trick is how to entice the gas companies to use this dirty water for their fracking operations, when they’re already allowed to help themselves to the clean water that people and wildlife need in order to live.

DEP’s white paper addresses this question by offering various ways to shield gas companies from liability. It also goes through the different permitting processes that might be required or, depending on politics, not. For instance, when it comes to storing MIW, option A is: The company must demonstrate that there will be no resulting water pollution, and must follow the parameters required by the EPA’s National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System.

Option B is: or not.

Any self-respecting environmentalist would love to see acid mine discharge cleaned up, and clean water left alone. If everything were to go right – no leaks, no spills, no cement casing failure, no lazy subcontractor dumping the flowback into the local river instead of taking it to the wastewater treatment plant – it actually could be a win-win situation. But if things were to go wrong, there could be 8,500 mine-polluted streams in Pennsylvania instead of 5,500, and we’ve already had enough examples of what can go wrong.

Is the answer to shelve the idea? No. But the most important goal shouldn’t be shielding the gas companies from liability, which for some of them would be like handing a child a book of matches and telling him he won’t get in trouble if he sets anything on fire.

Last summer Forbes magazine interviewed George Phydias Mitchell, who pioneered the fracking process in the 1990s. Mitchell said the government should tighten its regulation of fracking, not loosen it. He said, “There’s no excuse not to get it right,” and that if drillers “do something wrong and dangerous … (the government) should punish them.”

The Father of Fracking, laying down the law. Perhaps if the government did the same a bit more often, ideas such as using MIW for frackwater wouldn’t be so frightening.

© 2016 Shale Reporter . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • Discuss

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
  • 2 Don't Threaten or Abuse. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated. AND PLEASE TURN OFF CAPS LOCK.
  • 3 Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
  • 4 Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 5 Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 6 Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.

Welcome to the discussion.

1 comment:

  • Churchlady posted at 9:34 pm on Sun, Jul 14, 2013.

    Churchlady Posts: 1

    It would be very helpful if the Father of Fracking could tell us HOW to get it right. What geological formations are OK, what process is the best, what waste disposal is needed, and who, if anyone, IS doing it well. Details matter, and I'd LOVE to know answers, even complex ones, to these questions.


From the Ground Up: A trio of women bloggers provides insights, investigations and commentary on how Marcellus Shale issues affect our everyday lives.

Industry Eye: Mike Bulter explores the intricacies of natural resource extraction and its influence on local economy.
Subscribe to New Posts!
Enter your Email

Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

Miranda C. Spencer, a researcher with the online news sites Environmental Health News and The Daily Climate, is a freelance journalist and media critic based in the New York metro area. Her writing over the past 25 years, including eight magazine cover stories, has appeared in The Daily Climate, Extra! ( the journal of FAIR), E magazine, American Forests, and many other publications. Miranda's investigative work has been honored by Project Censored. Her website is Red Panda Communications.

Suzie Gilbert is a writer, a state and federally licensed wild bird rehabilitator, and the founder of Flyaway, Inc., a non-profit organization dedicated to the rescue, rehabilitation and release of injured and orphaned wild birds. She has written an award-winning environmental column for Taconic News Media, and has published the children's book "Hawk Hill" (Chronicle Books, 1996), and her memoir "Flyaway" (Harpercollins, 2009.) Her articles and opinion pieces have appeared in various newspapers, including the Washington Post. She blogs for "The Crooked Wing" and "10,000 Birds" and has been profiled in both the New York Times and on Andrew C. Revkin's New York Times blog, Dot Earth.

Tara’s academic work and pursuits are focused on eco-feminism and ethics. Tara has been featured on AOL’s as a weekly columnist, Moxie Momma, exploring social concerns and parenting strategies. Writing articles on lifestyle, entertainment and local travel, Tara has been a regular contributor to the Bethlehem, Hellertown and Upper Saucon Patch. As a research and investigative journalist, Tara’s work is regularly featured in the Elucidator Magazine. A specialist in the technical fields of psychology, philosophy and theology, Tara also teaches classes on Ethics and Moral Dilemmas, Death and Dying, World Religions, and Introduction to Philosophy.

Mike Butler serves as Executive Director of Consumer Energy Alliance (CEA) Mid-Atlantic, where he leads activities to educate and engage consumers of energy from every sector of the economy – large industrial natural gas users, small business, retail owners, hospitals, transportation, and local consumers. By focusing on the importance of responsibly accessing available natural resources and the need for stable energy prices for business, agriculture, manufacturing, and other energy consumers, CEA Mid-Atlantic aims to expand productive, sensible discussion on energy policy across the region. Prior to joining CEA Mid-Atlantic, Butler served as Finance Director for the re-election effort of U.S. Senator Bob Casey. After leading efforts to raise over $16 million for the Senator’s campaign, Mike’s was named to PoliticsPA’s “Top Operatives of 2012.” Additionally Mike served as District Director for Congressman Jason Altmire, Finance Director for Dan Onorato for Governor, and fundraiser for State Treasurer Rob McCord.